Thursday, September 9, 2010

Book: Good Men and True

Previously, we gave due regard to the early years of Eugene Manlove Rhodes in New Mexico, where he began as a writer. This time, let’s look at his first short novel, Good Men and True (1910).

Literacy was not uncommon among early cowboys. While whiskey, gambling, and women are the usual stereotype, accounts of the West show an appetite for reading that also ran deep. Not just dime novels, but anything in print. And that ranged from labels on canned goods to the classics. The Police Gazette was also a favorite, as Charlie Siringo recalled. Even the illiterate could “read the pictures.”

Bull Durham book list (see larger)
It’s worth remembering that packets of Bull Durham smoking tobacco came with coupons redeemable for paperbound books. There were, Rhodes says, 303 titles in this library of yellow-backed volumes, mostly fiction, all of them in the public domain. They included Rider Haggard, Oscar Wilde, Robert Louis Stevenson, A. Conan Doyle, James M. Barrie, and so on. You can see the entire list here. Since virtually all cowboys smoked, it didn’t take long for a bunkhouse to accumulate its own library.

Meanwhile, Rhodes has said that he grew up in a house with books: Shakespeare, Dickens, Scott, Whittier, Longfellow, Tennyson, Byron, Burns, Poe. And he obviously read them. The framework of his western stories is largely – though not totally– literary. He lovingly embeds the cowboy West into the great tradition of western literature.

There’s also a contemporary feel in them, akin to O. Henry and Twain. Good Men and True has their tongue-in-cheek cleverness in spades. Its plot is improbable and completely believable, because you want it to be, and its down-to-earth characters are thoroughly likable.

El Paso, 1886 (detail; click here to see entire map)
The plot. The story takes place in the sister cities of El Paso and Juarez (way out there at the western tip of Texas where the Rio Grande comes romancing out of New Mexico). Our hero is a 36-year-old cowboy by the name of Jeff Bransford. In the opening chapters, he befriends the clerk of a lawyer who owns the ranch where Bransford is foreman. The young clerk’s name, George Aughinbaugh, gets its own sentence.

George has recently arrived from Kansas City and is eager to make a new friend of Jeff. Their familiarity with the classics is quickly evident, and they have an entertaining conversation. Their attention visits for a moment the typewriter that the clerk has been using – that and a typing drill to improve dexterity on the machine: “Now is the time for all good men and true to come to the aid of their party.” Hence the book’s title and its plot in a nutshell.

The plot is set in motion by an attempted murder on the mean and darkened streets of frontier El Paso. Jeff, a witness to the incident, is kidnapped and held hostage in the cellar of a house across the river in Juarez. His captor is no riff-raff, but a wealthy politician and El Paso businessman by the name of Jack Thorpe. There follows a cat and mouse game in which Jeff tries to outwit Thorpe and escape.

Mac is subdued. Illustration by H. T. Dunn
Meanwhile, on receipt of a mysterious letter, Jeff’s fellow cowmen from the ranch, Billy Beebe, John Wesley Pringle, and Leo Ballinger, spring into action in search of their missing friend. With the help of George Aughinbaugh, they begin to unravel the mystery of his disappearance and whereabouts.

The clues are oblique and complex and, not surprisingly, involve the deciphering of literary allusions. But through feats of deduction that would impress the likes of Sherlock Holmes, they finally locate and rescue their friend. It is laugh-out-loud fun. The story was snapped up and serialized by the Saturday Evening Post in January 1910, before its publication as a book.

How western is it? Good question. There isn’t a ranch or a cow in sight. But the remnants of the Wild West that linger in El Paso provide the right ambiance. It’s surely the same El Paso where Pat Garrett hung out at his favorite saloon. In other words, “one awful tough town,” as one character puts it. Still, the story could take place in any city of the time with its share of corrupt public figures.

U of Nebraska Press, 1987
I’d argue that the West is there between the lines and in the character of the good men and true who grace its pages. Sun-weathered, seasoned, and tough to beat in a fight, Jeff Bransford has the indomitable spirit of a cowpuncher. His friends have the kind of cowpuncher loyalty to him and each other that drives them against all odds to his rescue.

They are decent, honest, and good-hearted working men. They’re given to a folk wisdom grounded in cowboy logic, as when John Harding Pringle says, “It’s a long worm that has no turning.” Their observations have the spirit of the West written all over them. As Jeff says of cowboys,

They have to ride and shoot – and speakin’ the truth comes easier for them than for some folks, ’cause if speaking the aforesaid truth displeases anyone, they mostly don’t give a damn.

And there is that attitude in the way the story is told, with its flights of gleeful circumlocution and sudden digressions. Offering a swallow of bottled first aid to George when he falls into excited confusion, J. W. Pringle assures him that it’s

a sovereign remedy for rattlesnake bites, burns, boils, sprains and bruises, fits, freckles and housemaid’s sore knee; excellent for chilblains, sunburn, congestion of the currency, inflammation of the ego, corns, verbosity, insomnia, sleeplessness, lying awake and bad dreams, punctuality, fracture of the Decalogue, forgetfulness, painful memory, congenital pip, the pangs of requited affection, mange, vivacity, rush of words to the head, old age and lockjaw.

And that’s only half the list. You read that comical assembly of mismatched and made-up ailments that range from the frivolous to the existential, and you marvel that it all came from the same mind.

Every chapter begins with a few lines of doggerel or a notable quote reflecting a lifetime of unmoderated reading. At chapter VI, for instance, there’s a snippet from Charles Edward Caryl’s “The Ballad of the Walloping Window Blind” which goes:

The bosun’s mate was very sedate,
            but fond of amusement too,
So he played hop-scotch with the larboard watch,
            while the Captain tickled the crew.


Characters can speak plainly and profanely, Jeff explains, “with useful words, easy and comfortable, like old clothes and old shoes.” Other times, he says, “my speech naturally rises in dignity to meet the occasion.” And even taken hostage and concerned for his life, he never loses his dignity. Fine language, even on the frontier, is the measure of the man.

Literary? Yes. So let’s call it cowboy lit.

More soon.

Further reading:
J. Frank Dobie, “A Salute to Gene Rhodes,” in The Best Novels and Short Stories of Eugene Manlove Rhodes, Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1949.

Picture credits:
1) Bull Durham book list,
2) Detail of map of El Paso, 1886,
3) Illustration from 1920 edition, illustrator H. T. Dunn
4) Book cover,

Coming up: The first westerns and more on Eugene Manlove Rhodes


  1. Loved the map of El Paso, I always had this idea, that towns like El Paso, were rickety, wooden built affairs. Maybe even adobe, but to see the grid system being layed out, as in the map, makes me realise that way back then, people had a need for the building of cities? Or maybe I am over simplifying.

  2. I love the idea of a bunch of cowboys sitting around reading Doyle and Haggard and people like that. Great stuff!

  3. I did not know that about Bull Durham and books. Wow, that is seriously cool. I wish some products would do that today.

  4. Another excellent review and I'm looking forward to your additional comments. The Bull Durham coupons was a great idea back then. Nowadays no one would send the coupons in! The illustration by Harvey Dunn is really excellent. Too bad the fiction magazines no longer exist that provided a great market for artwork.

  5. Cheyenne, I'm not sure how the grid system came into being for American cities, but it's pretty much the rule. Having a grid of streets also indicated the ambitions of the first residents for their settlement to become a city.

    Chris, I agree. It doesn't quite fit the stereotype.

    Charles, you have to wonder how the idea came up at the tobacco company. It was a different world then.

    Walker, thanks. Magazine illustration is such an art form unto itself. Completely taken for granted at the time but just crying out for appreciation today.

  6. The short excerpt about the bosun mate cracked me up. As a retired Navy type, I heard a lot of stories similar to this, but this one hit the nail on the head. It's amazing what you run across when reading older books.

  7. Oscar, Rhodes is full of this stuff. He was also fond of ALICE IN WONDERLAND. Says something about how his mind worked.

  8. Thanks for posting this list of the free books. I had wondered. Now I have a link to this for my Rhodes page It looks like they added "Alice" later.