Tuesday, April 17, 2012

The Rare Breed (1966)

Here’s a film that takes what may seem an unpromising premise and spins from it a heck of a western yarn. The premise has to do with the introduction of Hereford stock on the Texas plains and cross breeding them with Longhorns. That much is historical fact. The story woven around it is pure Hollywood.

Plot. Irish-born actress Maureen O’Hara plays the widow of an English cattle breeder. It’s 1884, and she shows up in St. Louis with her daughter (Juliet Mills) and a prize Hereford bull called Vindicator. The bull gets sold at auction to a Texas cattleman, and O’Hara persuades a cowpuncher (James Stewart) to deliver him to Texas.

There’s interference from another rancher, whose henchmen (Jack Elam and Harry Carey, Jr.) pay Stewart to turn the bull over to them instead. This scheme falls through when O’Hara and Mills insist on accompanying the bull all the way to Texas.

Elam, playing a nasty heavy, ambushes Stewart, the women, and the bull. He stampedes a herd of cattle being taken to market by handsome young Don Galloway. Stewart eliminates Elam, and everyone else is unscathed, except for Galloway, who has been badly injured.

Hereford bull
As they all finally arrive at the ranch in Texas, we discover that the bull’s buyer is Brian Keith, hidden behind a bush of facial hair and speaking a Scots accent broader than the Pecos. The injured cowhand is his son. Vindicator is released among the Longhorns and, with winter coming on, the women talk of returning to England.

Father and son have different ideas and are looking to wed them. Mills needs very little sweet talk to accept a hug and kiss from Galloway. O’Hara puts off the insistent Keith, even when he bathes, shaves, and shows up in regimental uniform (not a kilt) playing the bagpipes.

A bad winter decimates the Longhorn herd, and Vindicator himself does not survive. All except Stewart have lost faith in the future of crossbreeding. When a Longhorn mama cow is finally found with a Hereford calf, we learn that Vindicator has been doing his job. Stewart himself is vindicated, and O’Hara decides she’d rather spend the rest of her years with him instead of Keith.

History vs. myth. The crossbreeding of Longhorns with European stock was actually a big success. So much so that by 1927 Longhorns had been replaced on the range and were nearly extinct. The couple of hundred thousand of them that exist today are the result of government-funded efforts to restore the breed.

Texas Longhorn
I normally don’t pick on westerns for inaccuracies, but the lapses in this one are noticeable. The proper English women in the film ride astride their horses instead of sidesaddle, which would have been unthinkable for a respectable female. Stewart’s character is introduced as an expert modern-day style bulldogger, a rodeo event that was not invented until after 1900 by a black cowboy, Bill Pickett.

These gaffs are actually fairly easy to overlook, but on a really important subject like American geography, the film gets an F. Traveling to Texas from where the film starts in St. Louis involves a journey by train to Dodge City. Not the most direct route, but there’s the convenience factor of getting there by rail.

After that, the journey would require a weeks-long trek across several hundred miles of Kansas and what would have been Indian Territory. They accomplish this in a matter of days, in an open horse-drawn wagon with few supplies, and not a single mention of Indians. Shot entirely in California, the film fails to replicate the flat distances of the Plains. The cattle stampede takes place in a rocky canyon that is archetypal western, but only because it looks like someplace in the desert.

Maybe the most telling moment occurs near the end as Stewart picks up and carries off a newborn calf, without the slightest objection from its mother. In reality, it would have taken more than an expert bulldogger to survive an encounter with an outraged mama cow.

Novelization by Theodore Sturgeon
Wrapping up. OK, despite all that, The Rare Breed is still a lot of fun. There are some rollicking brawls and fistfights and a spectacular couple of stunts. The cast includes not only the incomparable Jack Elam but the incomparable Ben Johnson, who has an early scene on crutches.

Maureen O’Hara’s try for an upper-crust English accent doesn’t quite ring true, especially with English actress Juliet Mills as her daughter in the same scenes. But the two women are a gracefully determined presence in the film. Meanwhile, Brian Keith is truly funny as a Scots rancher. And James Stewart is himself, especially as he stumbles self-consciously in a conversation about breeding with Mills, who is unembarrassed by the subject.

The script was written by Ric Hardman, who is also credited as the writer for the TV series Lawman (1959-1961). Andrew Victor McLaglen directed. His credits include two John Wayne westerns, McClintock! (1963) and Chisum (1970), as well as many episodes of TV’s Have Gun—Will Travel and Gunsmoke.

One last note. Cullen Gallagher discusses Theodore Sturgeon’s novelization of the film over at Pulp Serenade. Readers there will learn that Sturgeon’s interest in historical authenticity seems to have far out-paced that of the film.

The Rare Breed is currently available at netflix and amazon. For more of Tuesday's Overlooked Movies click on over to Todd Mason's blog Sweet Freedom.

Photo credits: Wikimedia Commons

Coming up: Richard Prosch, Meadows Ford Blues

42 comments:

  1. Sturgeon was a good western writer on his own ticket, and in collaboration with ZANE GREY WESTERN MAGAZINE editor Don Ward, as I hope you've had the opportunity to find out...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My knowledge in this area is spotty. I've mostly known Sturgeon as the author of MORE THAN HUMAN.

      Delete
  2. That is a mightily attractive cast, quite aside from the sense in which Juliet Mills particularly might be attractive...(that video-box image of O'Hara doesn't flatter her).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right about O'Hara. The box makes her look like a drama queen in the film, a la Joan Crawford. She's not.

      Delete
  3. Andrew McLaglen was a fair actor himself. Not to the level of his dad Victor who was a mainstay in many John Ford movies including the Quiet Man, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon etc but a fine actor in his own right.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Okay, finally a movie that I know! We used to rent this one on VHS before all the local video stores went out of business. You're right, it is fun, even with its flaws. Personally I thought Brian Keith and Juliet Mills were the scene-stealers - they seemed much more natural than the rest of the cast (except Ben Johnson, of course, but his role was so brief). And there's a nice score by John (credited as Johnny) Williams too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for identifying the composer. The music does reflect his kind of sensibility.

      Delete
  5. This brought back memories. Especially the Hereford bull picture.

    I worked for a farmer/rancher who raised purebred Hereford's and he had two prize bulls: Liberty and Mac. Massive animals. First day at work, Mr. Towns handed me a bucket of grain, pointed to Liberty and said "Go feed him." You couldn't do it from outside the corral, either. Wowzers. Best job I ever had.

    I haven't seen the movie in years, but can still remember the final scene clear as day. And I always liked Jimmy Stewart as a cowboy, which seemed to bring out an edge in him.

    Thanks for the review, and the memories, Ron.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Grew up among Herefords as well, though I believe I never had the temerity to get in the same pen with a bull. That's quite a memory.

      Delete
  6. That doesn't look like Maureen O'Hara at all. She was such a great actress, so good at playing nice women without making them overly sentimental.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She starts out stiffly British and refuses to be intimidated by the men she encounters. It's interesting to watch how she "softens" later in the film, her mission accomplished and uncertain about her prospects.

      Delete
  7. The main reason why pet owners choose to insure their pets is to lower their vet bills, and to have healthy pets the same time. cat carrier insurance policies will pay a significant amount of the cost of your vet bills.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I must say, as a lot as I enjoyed reading what you had to say, I couldnt help but lose interest after a while. Its as if you had a wonderful grasp on the subject matter, but you forgot to include your readers. Perhaps you should think about this from far more than one angle. Or maybe you shouldnt generalise so considerably. Its better if you think about what others may have to say instead of just going for a gut reaction to the subject. Think about adjusting your own believed process and giving others who may read this the benefit of the doubt. Best Hemp Oil For Cats

    ReplyDelete
  9. It's moving day for you and your pet! Your house is all packed up and you're waiting for the movers to arrive. You've gone through your pre-moving day pet checklist...new pet ID tags - check, pet travel carrier - check, booked pet friendly hotels & accommodations - check, etc... You're not out of the woods yet! Here are the top 5 moving day tips for pets! king charles cavalier spaniel

    ReplyDelete
  10. login joker123 di bermacam- macam tipe game dengan terencana memperkenalkan keuntungan signifikan. Yang mana keuntungan tersebut dapat membuat pemainnya merasa bahagia bukan kepalang sampai menimbulkan pemainnya mau melakukan judi online pada “Joker123: Daftar Situs Slot Online & Joker388 Terbaik Di Indonesia”. login joker123

    ReplyDelete
  11. Bila kamu mencari web joker388 via online dengan mengetik kata kunci bermain judi online, telah tentu terdapat ribuan web yang menawarkan keunggulan ataupun keuntungannya. Tetapi, tidak seluruh web dapat diberikan keyakinan. Sejatinya, web terpercaya telah lebih dahulu membagikan keunggulan serta keuntungan demi kepuasan pemain cuma Situs Login Joker123 Online Terbaik Dengan Winrate Tertinggi No 1. joker388

    ReplyDelete
  12. Era serba mutahir serta segalanya telah serba digital. Kemudahan menempuh kegiatan terus menjadi signifikan pada tiap waktunya. Tercantum dengan melakukan taruhan Web slot deposit pulsa. Di seluruh tipe keadaan, bermain judi slot via online jauh lebih mengasyikkan serta lebih seru dibanding melakukan nya di tempat kasino. Saat ini kamu dapat dengan gampang melakukan taruhan kapan saja serta dimana saja yang kamu ingin kala bermain Situs judi bola tangkas online terpercaya dengan pelayanan cepat 24 jam. slot deposit pulsa

    ReplyDelete
  13. Memilih Taruhan Bola Online Di Situs Terpercaya

    Judi bola online sangatlah booming di berbagai kalangan masyarakat dunia salah satunya di Indonesia ini. Banyaknya para penggemar judi bola online sehingga orang beramai-ramai untuk mencari situs judi bola online yang terpercaya untuk bermain di dalamnya.

    Seiring berjalanya waktu teknologi semakin hari semakin canggih apapun yang kalian ingin cari tahu pasti ada di internet termasuk situs judi bola online ini. Salah satu situus judi bola online yang paling terpercaya dan terbaik di Indonesia adalah agen sbobet 389sports dimana agen sbobet yang satu ini sudah menjadi agen sbobet sejak tahun 2017 sampai detik ini masih menjadi agen terbaik untuk para pengguna setiap judi bola online.

    Jadi tunggu apalagi langsung saja bergegas dan bermain judi bola di agen sbobet sebagai situs judi bola terpercaya. Mainkan game bola online hanya dengan satu ID saja.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Saat ini Situs poker online yang senantiasa dimainkan tiap harinya telah disematkan dengan keunggulan serta keuntungan tertentu. Sebab biasanya, kedatangan Agen Judi Poker Terpercaya Dengan Winrate Tertinggi di Indonesia tinggi di Indonesia dengan terencana berdiri tegak serta mewakilkan perjudian yang lain buat membagikan rasa bahagia yang sempurna. situs poker online

    ReplyDelete
  15. Mari lekas mainkan Slot pragmatic dengan RTP yang besar serta seleksi provider serta agen judi online formal yang sangat pas, provider yang memiliki RTP serta jackpot judi terbanyak sehingga peluang menang kamu terus menjadi besar, tunggu terlebih lekas catatan serta mainkan cuma di Situs Slot Pragmatic & Agen Slot Deposit Pulsa Terbaik. slot pragmatic

    ReplyDelete
  16. Situs Resmi Judi Slot Pragmatic Play Versi 389Sports

    Dalam bermain game slot online siapa sih yang tidak ingin mendapatkan uang berlimpah. Dimana untuk bisa mendapatkan nya dengan sangat mudah dan gampang, kalian bisa coba untuk bermai game slot dari slot pragmatic play dimana situs yang satu ini sangat menguntungkan untuk para penggunanya.

    Terlebih itu kalian bisa mendapatkan kesenangan untuk hiburan ketika bosan dalam menunggu waktu sambil bermain game slot pragmatic dari 389Sports kalian bisa mendapatkan cuan yang sangat berlimpah ketika memainkanya. Daftar sekarang dapatkan bonus new member sebesar 20% pada saat setelah selesai mendaftar.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Pada jaman sekarang ini sangatlah mudah bisa menghasilkan uang dengan Smartphone kalian saja. Pasalnya, hampir seluruh kegiatan bisa dilakukan dengan system online. Seperti yang kebanyakan orang salah satunya melakukan perjudian online. Permainan judi slot ini adalah taruhan online yang banyak di minati di seluruh dunia. Pastinya yang selalu dilakukan oleh kebanyakn orang bermain di situs judi slot joker123 versi 389sports sangat banyak beragam keuntungan yang kalian dapatkan.

    Padahal, keuntungan ini selalu tersedia bagi seluruh anggota member slot joker123 yang memiliki modal rendah. Banyaknya wahana permainan judi slot yang bisa menghasilkan uang hingga ratusan juta rupiah dengan bermain slot joker123 di Smartphone kalian dengan mudah. Oleh sebab itu, situs judi slot joker123 ini sangatlah populer dan bnayak di gemari oleh para kalangan di seluruh dunia.

    Untuk proses pendaftaran kalian bisa langsung kunjungi situs resmi judi slot joker123 versi 389sports ini dimana klaian akan mendapatkan kemudahan serta keuntungan yang sangat luar bisa yang belum di miliki di situs judi slot online manapun. Situs ini sudah di resmikan dan tentu meiliki lisensi resmi sehingga kalian tidak perlu khawatir lagi dalam bermain judi slot joker123 ini. Daftar sekarang juga dapatkan langsung bonus new member sebesar 20% bonus saldo bisa langsung masuk ke akun kalian dapat di gunakan untuk taruhan di slot joker123 mainkan sekarang juga.

    ReplyDelete
  18. 389Sports merupakan agen judi slot online resmi yang menyediakan permainan joker123 login dengan bonus yang berlimpah untuk para pemainnya. Dimana game slot Joker123 login ini banyak diminati oleh kaula muda yang ada di Indonesia. Selain itu, permainan ini sangat mudah dimainkan, Anda hanya perlu melakukan registrasi akun kemudian memasang taruhan dan menekan tombol main dalam permainan slot pilihan anda.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Play Sbobet Soccer Gambling at the Best & Trusted 389Sports Official Agent

    An online soccer gambling agent is definitely needed where it will be very useful to help new members in the registration process. Moreover, this official sbobet site is very large and needs the best sbobet agent to handle the registration process.

    The best and most trusted sbobet agent that you can find in Indonesia is the 389Sports site where this official agent has been a sbobet agent since 2016 and is still the main choice for new users who want to register for an official sbobet ID account. It is very easy to register for this official sbobet account, you can directly click on the list menu on the sbobet site and you will be directed to the registration section. After that, you can immediately complete the required part of the registration form correctly. So what are you waiting for, just register and play online sbobet soccer gambling for free and get a new member bonus of 50% upon completion of registration.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Bermain game 88tangkas online uang asli serta Tangkasnet, 88Tangkas dan Bolatangkas di 389Sports tidak hanya diakses melalui laptop atau komputer. Canggihnya agen Tangkasnet 389Sports dengan menyediakan software yang bisa didownload ataupun langsung main di website resminya melalui handphone Anda melalui Android ataupun i0s. Ini akan membuat Anda maupun pemain setia judi tangkas terpercaya uang asli 389Sports dapat lebih praktis dalam mencari keuntungan maupun hiburan melewati game judi tangkas online di Indonesia. Apabila Anda mengalami kesulitan dalam bermain judi tangkas, Anda tidak perlu cemas sebab Customer Service (CS) website Agen Tangkasnet Terpercaya 389Sports akan siap standby 24jam nonstop untuk melayani segala macam bentuk pertanyaan Anda.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Tidak hanya slot saja joker388 sudah menjadi permainan yang sangat terkenal yang memang memberikan jumlah bonus yang sangat besar apalagi ketika dimainkan melalui situs 389Sports anda akan mendapatkan banyak bonus ketika bermain joker388 di situs 389Sports ini, tidak perlu menunggu dan langsung saja cek situs 389Sports sekarang juga dan daftar mainkan joker388

    ReplyDelete
  22. Dengan jumlah pemain yang sangat banyak dengan permainan slot pragmatic tentu anda tidak akan pernah sendiri atau melawan bot ketika bermain slot pragmatic karena dengan banyaknya pemain aktif anda akan selalu menemukan pemain asli, bermain dan bertarung untuk jackpot Bersama, semakin banyak yang main slot pragmatic maka akan semakin tinggi jackpot yang anda dapatkan

    ReplyDelete
  23. Agen Sbobet, Daftar Akun Judi Bola Online Di 389Sports Banyak Untungnya

    Dalam hal memilih agen sbobet resmi kalian harus memperhatikan beberapa faktor terlebih dahulu karena itu akan menjadi sebuah tempat taruhan yang akan kalian langsungkan. Pastinya di agen sbobet resmi sudah memiliki minimal lisensi resmi dari PAGCOR sehingga ketika bermain di situs sbobet itu data kalian akan tetap terjaga.

    Biasanya dari kebanyakan masyarakat indonesia mendaftarkan dirinya di agen resmi sbobet 389Sports karena agen yang satu ini sudah menjadi partner sbobet sejak tahun 2015 sampai saat ini masih berdiri tegak untuk menangani proses pendafatrakn akun sbobet resmi. Mendafarkan diri di agen sbobet ini tentu kalian akan mendapatkan bonus new member langsung sebesar 50% pada saat selesai pendaftaran bukan hanya bonus itu saja melainkan masih banyak lagi bonus sbobet yang bisa kalian dapatkan hingga ratusan juta rupiah.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Di dalam situs joker388 deposit pulsa yang bisa diakses melalui link alternatif 389sports, Anda bisa menjumpai berbagai macam permainan slot online, live casino hingga judi tembak ikan online dengan beragam jackpot yang berlimpah menanti Anda. Tidak hanya itu, jika Anda bergabung bersama kami maka Anda juga bisa mendapatkan bonus new member antara 10%-50%, bonus cashback 10% dan bahkan bonus deposit pulsa yang bisa diklaim ketika Anda melakukan deposit dengan besar 10%. Cukup menarik bukan?

    ReplyDelete
  25. Playing Mix Parlay Soccer Gambling at the Best Wap Sbobet Agent 389Sports

    Of course, you are already familiar with this mix parlay bet because almost everyone knows and has played this mix parlay game. At the official 389Sports sbobet wap agent, you can play mix parlays to be able to earn extraordinary income.

    The presence of sbobet wap is very helpful for money seekers because it is very easy to win. The prizes at the sbobet wap agent that have been provided are many, which is the main reason for players to play sbobet wap soccer gambling at 389Sports. Don't wait any longer, just register yourself on the best and most trusted official sbobet wap in Indonesia.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hanya bola tangkas saja yang menjadi tempat bermain sangat ramai di Indonesia karena sangat ramai anda tentu akan mendapatkan jumlah jackpot yang sangat besar ketika anda bermain tangkasnet apalagi ketika anda memainkannya di situs 389Spots yang selalu siap untuk memberikan yang terbaik kepada customer dengan memiliki live service dengan kualitas yang tentu saja 24 jam selalu online, langsung main bola tangkas di 389Sports sekarang juga

    ReplyDelete
  27. Daftar Judi Bola Sbobet Online Di Link Alternatif Terpercaya 389Sports

    Sebuah situs agen sbobet terbaik dan terpercaya yaitu 389Sports menyediakan berbagai macam kebutuhan anda dalam hal proses pendaftaran. Kalian akan dengan sangat mudah mendaftar di agen sbobet resmi 389Sports ini karena tersedia link alternatif sbobet yang bisa anda gunakan ketika mendaftar judi bola sbobet resmi.link alternatif sbobet

    Tidak susah untuk menemukan link alternatif sbobet terbaru dan terupdate di agen terpercaya 389Sports sebab kami adalah agen terbaiknya yang di percayai oleh situs utama SBOBET. Terlebih itu kalian akan mendapatkan berbagai bonus apabila bergabung menggunakan link alternatif sbobet yang sudah di sediakan. Akses ratusan permainan judi bola online hanya dengan menggunakan satu user ID link alternatif sbobet. Daftar dan mainkan sekarang juga!!!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Ada banyak permainan ceme online diluar sana tetapi tentu hanya sedikit permainan ceme online yang akan memberikan anda banyka event ketika anda ingin bermain ceme online maka dari itu tunggu apalagi dan algnsung saja bermain ceme online di situs 389Sports dan raih hadiah yang sanga tbesar sekarang juga

    ReplyDelete
  29. Taruhan Handicap Di Situs Bola Online Terpercaya 389Sports

    Bola online kini sudah menjadi kegiatan sehari-hari dalam melakukan hiburan, hobby, serta bisa dapat mencari keuntungan di situs bola login sbobet online. 389Sports ini memeiliki berbagai macam taruhan bola online salah satunya handicap ini.

    Untuk memulai sebuah taruhan kalian harus login sbobet terlebih dahulu atau mendaftarkan diri apabila belum memiliki akun. Di login sbobet ini kalian akan memulai sebuah taruhan bola online yang kalian sukai hanya menggunakan satu User ID saja. Daftar dan mainkan sekarang login sbobet bersama para member lainya.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Bermain slot online terpercaya tentu akan membuat anda mendapatkan banyak uang ketika anda selalu bermain slot online gacor karena tidak semua slot yang anda mainkan akan gacor alias memberikan anda banyak keuntungan maka dari itu mulailah bermain di situs 389Sports sekarang juga dan mainkan slot online gacor agar anda bisa mendapatkan keuntungan yang sangat banyak dan sangat cepat sekarang juga

    ReplyDelete
  31. 389Sports: Gacor Slot88 Game | The Best Online Gambling Sites In Indonesia

    Many already know that there is an situs judi online from 389Sports because it is very popular with the games it provides, which are very interesting and profitable. On this situs judi online, you can play several gacor slot games using only one User ID.

    Moreover, this situs judi online has various types of transactions that you can easily enjoy using either E-wallet, Local Bank, or Cellular Credit. The service on this situs judi online is 24 hours non-stop so that it can help bettors who want to make deposits or withdrawals at the trusted situs judi online 389Sports.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Semua orang pastinya sudah mengetahui tentang permainan judi bola Sbobet Indonesia tidak asing lagi di kalangan para pencinta judi bola online, permainan judi bola online sendiri sudah berdiri sejak lama dan pada akhirnya menjadi populer di berbagai kalangan masyarakat dunia oleh karena itu situs judi bola sbobet indonesia banyak penggemarnya. Permainan sepak bola sendiri sangatlah di cintai di oleh seluruh orang di dunia salah satunya di kita sendiri yaitu Indonesia. Mulai dari remaja bahkan sampai orang dewasa bermain judi bola sbobet indonesia ini. judi bola

    ReplyDelete
  33. Kemudahan bertransaksi di situs slot deposit pulsa tanpa potongan di agen terbaik resmi 389Sports. Setiap para bettor yang ingin melakukan sebuah taruhan di situs slot online tentu harus memiliki saldo terlebih dahulu. Oleh sebab itu kalian bisa bertransaksi di slot deposit pulsa ini selain gampang kalian tidak akan di kenakan potongan. Sudah banyak orang yang bertransaksi menggunakan situs slot deposit pulsa ini kerana sangat mudh digunakan.

    ReplyDelete
  34. So many people have the misconception that rescued dogs are less than other dogs. Why do we assume homeless pets are less than other pets? I'd like to help set the record straight: there are many reasons to adopt a shelter pet. pet food

    ReplyDelete